PLSC 475 Contemporary Political Theory

The course has two primary purposes. The first purpose is to survey a cross section of some important political writings from the last few decades. The second purpose is to facilitate the development of a compelling account of our politics, an account of where we sit right now as citizens, students, and critical observers of contemporary politics. The texts we will read have been selected because they are representative of the questions confronted by political theorists in the recent past. But they have also been selected with an eye toward developing a status report on the state of affairs in contemporary political life.

We will focus on two main topics–power and identity–with an emphasis on the relationship between the two, on the way the two interact to mutually constitute one another. Students are invited to reflect on the role played in this process by (among others): democracy, rights, citizenship, the state, class, race, gender, sexual orientation, consumerism, nationalism, populism, and imperialism.

LEARNING OUTCOMES:

Students will:

1. Demonstrate critical thinking, writing and research skills.

2. Demonstrate knowledge of the most important developments in contemporary political theory.

3. Apply theory to specific developments in contemporary politics.

4. Apply an international or cross-cultural perspective.

 

REQUIRED TEXTS: Some assignments are available on Blackboard. In addition, the books listed below must be purchased or borrowed. I have included links to Amazon, but you should feel free to get them from preferred vendor.

Texts must be brought to class on the day they will be discussed.  Students will be considered absent if they do not bring the reading to class on the discussed.  Texts from Blackboard must be printed out and brought in hard copy as electronic devices are not permitted in class.

GENERAL INFORMATION: This course will emphasize critical reading and analysis of the assigned texts. Class meetings will be primarily discussion based. Readings must be completed before the class meeting in which they will be discussed. This enables students to get the most out of the lectures and to participate effectively in discussion.

Discussion: During class discussion you are not expected to have fully developed points of view about the course materials, but you are expected to participate. You will be rewarded for trying; you will not be penalized for being wrong or unclear, but it should be clear that you have done the readings and are working toward mastery of the material.

Aggressive Reading: Unlike other courses in which you read to complete an assignment—in which you read in order to read every word—you will benefit most from this course by reading aggressively. Rather than attempting to read every word, you should attempt to understand and ponder every idea. That may allow you to skim/skip repetitive paragraphs, or you may need to read some sections two or three times. The key is that you read for understanding, not completion. You are most likely to do this if you read with a pen and paper in which you write down ideas, questions, quotes, points of confusion, and points of disagreement.

Questions: None of us, myself included, knows everything about the topics of this class. It is our responsibility to ask others who may know the answer, either in class, in office hours, or over dinner. I expect that you are learning the material, not that you know it. As much as possible, try not to be shy or embarrassed about what you don’t yet know. The biggest failure in learning any material, in college or in life, is to fail to ask questions about things you do not know.

Availability: I expect that all of you, either alone or in groups, will contact me at some point during the semester. I am available to discuss the course material, either during office hours, at other times, over the phone, or through email.  If you would prefer to schedule a time during non-office hours, simply contact me by phone or email and we will schedule an appropriate time.

Laptops and Cell Phones, and Tablets: Neither laptops nor tablets may be used in class.  Cell phones must be turned off AND put away during class meetings.  Students who use laptops, tablets, or cell phones will be considered absent.

EVALUATION CRITERIA:

  • Weekly Assignments:  30%
  • Status Report:  30%
  • Midterm:  15%
  • Final Exam: 15%
  • In-class participation:  10%

Weekly Assignments:  On the Schedule of Meetings (below), you will find study questions for each class session.  On the first day of class, students will be assigned questions for each week.  All students are responsible for writing approximately 1-2 pages in response to these questions.  The weekly assignments must be brought to class so that they can be used in our discussion.  Students will be discussion leaders for the questions they have answered.  These assignments should be handed in at the end of class each week. In these assignments, you should feel free to answer the questions not only as they pertain to the texts but also with reference to contemporary political issues.

The weekly assignments will be assessed on a scale of 1-5.  A “3″ indicates that the student has accurately grasped the reading.  A “4″ is indicative of a grasp of the reading with some critical reflection.  A “5″ indicates critical reflection as well as specific reference to the text.  A “2″ indicates that the answer misrepresents the text, while a “1″ indicates that the question has not been answered.  At the end of the semester the grade for these assignments will be calculated as follows:

  • mostly 4s and 5s = A
  • mostly 3s = B
  • mostly below 3s = C, D, or F

Status Report: Students are required to write a 5000-word status report on contemporary American politics. What is going well? What isn’t? This is obviously a broad assignment. It will be up to you to specify your focus. First, you you should decide how broadly or narrowly you wish to define “contemporary.” Second, you will need to pick an area of emphasis. You might start by looking at the topics mentioned in the course description. Your status report may refer to outside sources but must also address at least two of the assigned texts.

Students must upload a 1-2 page outline to SafeAssign on Blackboard (by 11:59 pm after class in week 3. Outlines must include a thesis statement. On the dates given below, students must upload 1500 words of their research by 11:59 pm. Original work must be submitted on each occasion. I will return this work with comments and suggestions. The completed final draft will be due on Sunday before finals week at 11:59 pm.  Late papers will be penalized at the rate of one grade per day. All papers must be submitted in Microsoft Word. No PDFs.

Exams: The midterm and the final exam will be composed of a selection of the study questions given below.

In-Class Participation: Class participation will be measured based on attendance and preparedness (i.e. whether students are prepared to discuss the reading in class). Students who miss more than three classes will automatically suffer a deduction of one-third of a grade (e.g. a B+ becomes a B).  Students who miss more than six classes will suffer a full grade deduction (e.g. a B+ becomes a C+). Students who use laptops, tablets, or cell phones will be considered absent.

SCHEDULE OF MEETINGS AND REQUIRED READINGS:

(For all of the assigned readings, please begin by noting when the text was published, why the author wrote it, and to whom the author was responding.)

INTRODUCTION

Feb. 2:

George Monbiot, “Neoliberalism” (https://www.theguardian.com/books/2016/apr/15/neoliberalism-ideology-problem-george-monbiot)

Umberto Eco, “Ur-fascism” (http://www.nybooks.com/articles/1995/06/22/ur-fascism/)

PROCEDURALISM

Feb. 9:

Dahl, “Procedural Democracy” (Blackboard)

Group 1___PB, MB, HB, TC, RV _

  • What persons have a rightful claim to be included s citizens with full and equal rights to participate in governing?
  • What are the conditions for democratic decision-making?
  • What is Dahl’s criterion for political equality?
  • What is effective participation?

Group 2____SD, IE, BG, AG, LR_

  • Why is some measure of enlightenment necessary for democracy?
  • What does it mean to say the demos is sovereign?
  • What is the role of delegation in a democracy?
  • What are the qualifications for inclusion in the demos?
  • What is Dahl’s critique of Schumpeter?

Group 3___HH, CM, NN, MP, DA, NC__

  • Should those unqualified to govern be permitted to do so?
  • Why are children so important to Dahl’s argument?
  • What is the principle of equal consideration?
  • What are the best objections to procedural democracy?
  • What rights, if any, are required by Dahl’s argument?

Thomas Pogge, “Migration and Poverty” (Blackboard)

Group 1___SD, NN, CM, HB, RV__

  • What obligations, if any, do nations have to migrants?

Group 2___PB, HH, TC, MB, LR, NC__

  • Why does Pogge favor poverty mitigation to migration?
  • Should political refugees be treated differently from economic migrants?

Group 3___MP, AG, IE, BG, DA___

  • If we opt for foreign aid, how should it be distributed?
  • Where does Pogge suggest the funds for foreign aid could come from?

John Rawls, “Justice as Fairness” (Blackboard)

Group 1__PB, MP, SD, AG, RV, NC_____

  • What are the two principles of justice?
  • What types of inequality are just? What types are unjust?

Group 2___HH, NN, IE, TC, LR____

  • How is Rawls’ position different from utilitarianism?
  • How does Rawls derive the two principles of justice?

Group 3___CM, BG, MB, HB, DA___

  • What determines whether a practice is fair?
  • What is the general position?
  • What is Rawls’ critique of utilitarianism?

Feb. 16:

Nozick, “Distributive Justice” (Blackboard)

Group 1___TC, AG, IE, BG, DA____

  • What is the entitlement theory?
  • What makes a distribution just?
  • Does a just distribution depend on how people came to possess their holdings?

Group 2___MP, HH, PB, MB, RV, NC___

  • How does liberty upset attempts to pattern distribution?
  • Why is taxation a system of forced labor?
  • What is the Lockean limitation on property rights?

Group 3___SD, NN, CM, HB, LR___

  • What is Nozick’s critique of Rawls?
  • Are people entitled to their natural assets?
  • Why does Nozick only accept rectification as grounds for redistribution?

Sandel, “The Procedural Republic” (Blackboard)

Group 1___MP, HH, IE, MB, NC,  RV____

  • What is the difference between the right and the good?
  • What is the unencumbered self? What does it get wrong?
  • How does Sandel criticize Kant?

Group 2___SD, NN, PB, HB, LR____

  • What is Sandel’s critique of the difference principle?
  • What is the dark side of the encumbered self?

Group 3___AG, CM, BG, TC, DA____

  • What is our present predicament?
  • What is the procedural republic?

Feb. 17: STATUS REPORT OUTLINE DUE

CITIZENSHIP

February 23:

Arendt, Human Condition, pp. 22-78 (Blackboard)

Group 1____AG, HH, PB, HB, DA___

  • What defines humans as human?
  • What is the distinctive feature of the polis? What separates it from the household?
  • Why has the the line between the household and polis been blurred for us?
  • What is the sphere of freedom?
  • How did he Greeks view a purely private life?
  • What provoked Rousseau’s emphasis on the intimate?

Group 2___SD, NN, MB, BG, RV____

  • How is modern “society” different from the ancients’ “political realm”?
  • What is the difference between government and administration?
  • What is Arendt’s critique of the behavioral sciences?
  • What are the pleasures of the private realm?
  • What is the basis of the Christian community?
  • How was the private realm necessary for the public realm?

Group 3___MP, CM, IE, TC, LR, NC_____

  • Why do the moderns hold wealth sacred?
  • How has the decline of the public realm undermined the private realm as well?
  • What role do women play in the public realm?
  • What distinguishes the public from the private?
  • What’s wrong with Christian goodness?

Schmitt, The Concept of the Political, pp. 19-37 (Blackboard)

Group 1_____NN, MP, TC, PB, DA_____

  • What is the concept of the political?
  • What’s wrong with existing definitions of the political?

Group 2_____MB, CM, AG, HB, RV, NC___

  • How did democracy change the definition of politics?
  • What is the relationship between state and society?
  • What is the nature of the friend-enemy distinction?

Group 3____BG, IE, HH, SD, LR ______

  • How does the friend-enemy distinction vary from society to society?
  • How is war related to the friend-enemy distinction?
  • Can the friend-enemy distinction be overcome?

POWER

March 2:

Foucault, “Power, Right, Truth” (Blackboard)

Group 1_______BG, MB, HH, MP, RV_

  • What is the relationship between truth and power?
  • What is a discourse?

Group 2_____AG, HB, CM, SD, LR____

  • What is the field of application of power?
  • What is the locus of power? Where does it reside?
  • How is power employed and executed?

Group 3_____PB, TC, NN, IE, DA, NC_____

  • What is an ascending analysis of power?
  • What’s wrong with studying sovereignty?
  • What is disciplinary power?

Foucault, Security, Territory, Population, Introduction, ch. 1; Foucault/Chomsky Debate

Group 1___HH, CM, NN, MP, LR, NC___

  • What are governmentality and pastoral power?  What is the relationship between the two? p. xviii-xix
  • What is the appeal of “conduct” for Foucault? p. xix
  • “Resistance is ‘coextensive and absolutely contemporaneous’ to power.” (p. xx)  What are the implications of this, especially for those who would resist power?
  • Give an example of what Foucault calls “counter-conduct?” p. xxiii
  • What is ascesis? p. xxiii

Group 2___SD, IE, BG, AG, RV__

  • What is the relationship between morality, moral conduct, and pracitices of the self? p. xxiv
  • What are the components of “care of the self?” p. xxiv
  • What is the relationship between power and freedom? p. xxiv
  • What is asceticism?  Why isn’t Christianity ascetic? p. xxiv-xxv
  • What is the “‘juridification’ of moral and political experience?” p. xxvi

Group 3__PB, MB, HB, TC, DA__

  • What is the relevance of J.S. Mill to Foucault’s argument? p. xxvii
  • What is truly radical about homosexuality?  What might Foucault think of gay marriage? p. xxviii
  • “Probably the principal objective today is not to discover but to refuse what we are?”  What is the meaning of this claim? p. xxx
  • Why not “behave yourself?” p. xxxii
  • What is “bio-power?” p. 1

Group 4__TC, AG, IE, BG, DA____

  • From where do mechanisms of power emerge? p. 2
  • On what basis does Foucault define philosophy as “the politics of truth?” p. 3
  • Foucault frames his analysis around struggle.  What must one know if one wants to struggle? p. 3
  • What is the difference between the two “modulations” penalizing stealing? p. 4
  • What effects of the second modulation of punishment is Foucault interested in exploring? p. 4

Group 5____MP, HH, PB, MB, LR, NC___

  • How do the different penal forms map on different historical periods? p. 6
  • What is the role of history in philosophy? p. 8
  • What does Foucault mean by “security?” p. 10
  • What is an apparatus (dispositif)? p. 11
  • What is population? How does it emerge historically? p. 11

Group 6__SD, NN, CM, HB, RV___

  • What are the targets of sovereignty, discipline, and security? p. 11
  • What was the apparatus of governance in the 18th-century European town? p. 18
  • What is the difference between discipline and security as models of governance? p. 19

March 9:

Foucault, Security, Territory, Population, ch. 2 (pp. 44-49), ch. 3 (pp. 63-79), ch. 4,, ch. 5, ch. 7 (pp. 183-5), ch. 8 (pp. 191-7), ch. 10 ( pp. 273-5)

Group 1___SD, NN, CM, HB, RV___

  • What are the three differences between discipline and security? pp. 44-46
  • Law works “in the imaginary.” (p. 47)  What is the meaning of this claim?
  • “Freedom is nothing else but the correlative of the deployment of apparatuses of security.” (p. 48)  What is the meaning of this claim?
  • How does Foucault use the term “ideology?” p. 49
  • What is the relationship between a law and a norm? p. 56
  • Why is the town important in the shift from discipline to security? pp. 63-4
  • Why was the town “free” under feudalism in a way that the rest of the territory was not? p. 64
  • What is the “problem of circulation?” p. 64

Group 2___PB, HH, TC, MB, DA, NC____

  • How is Foucault’s analysis different from Machiavelli’s? p. 65
  • What is a panopticon?  Why is it archaic? p. 66
  • How and why did the concept “population” change in the 17th century? p. 68
  • What is required for the population to serve the state’s power and strength? p. 69
  • What are mercantilists and physiocrats? p. 70
  • How does the physiocrats’ view of population differ from the mercantilists’ view? p. 70
  • What techniques are available for controlling the population on the physiocrats’ (security) model? p. 72

Group 3____MP, AG, IE, BG, LR___

  • What unites a diverse population? p. 72
  • What series of knowledges emerges with population? p. 76
  • “Man…, as he is reflected in nineteenth century humanism, is nothing other than a figure of population.” (p. 79)  What does Foucault mean?  What are the implications of this claim?
  • “For Machiavelli, the Prince exists in a relationship of singularity and externality, of transcendence, to his principality.” (p. 91)  What does Foucault mean by this?
  • What are the consequences of the externality of the Prince? pp. 91-2
  • What is the “art of government?” (p. 92)  Why is it missing in Machiavelli?
  • What are the three types of government? p. 93
  • How does La Perrière’s definition of government differ from Machiavelli’s? p. 96

Group 4__PB, MP, SD, AG, DA_____

  • Why does the importance of law recede for La Perrière? p. 99
  • Why, according to La Perrière, should a good ruler rule like a bumblebee? p. 100
  • What were the conditions for the emergence of the art of government? p. 103
  • What role do statistics play in the art of government? p. 104
  • How does the family change with the emergence of population? p. 105
  • What role do sovereignty and discipline play in the new era of population? p. 107
  • What does Foucault mean by “governmentality?” p. 108
  • What are the three stages of governmentality?  What characterizes each one? p. 110

Group 5___HH, NN, IE, TC, LR____

  • What is a “technology of power?” p. 117
  • “Madness exists, which does not mean that it is a thing.”  What does this mean? p. 118
  • What did “government” connote in the 13th, 14th, and 15th centuries? p. 121-2
  • How is the Greco-Roman model of governance different from the Hebrew model? pp. 122-25
  • What differences between the Greek gods and the Hebrew God does Foucault emphasize? p. 125
  • What is Greco-Roman power if not beneficent? p. 126
  • Why is pastoral power uniquely individualizing? p. 128
  • Why is the pastorate so important to governmentality? p. 184

Group 6___CM, BG, MB, HB, RV, NC____

  • What are the forms of resistance to pastoral power? p. 195
  • What was the Western pastorate founded against? pp. 195-6
  • How did Christianity deal with with Medieval counter-conduct? pp. 215
  • At the start of the seventeenth century, what new knowledge was required for one who governs? p. 273-4
  • Why do statistics become important at the start of the seventeenth century? p. 274
  • What is the “problem of the public?” p. 275

March 10: FIRST INSTALLMENT OF STATUS REPORT DUE (1500 WORDS)

March 16: SPRING BREAK

PATRIARCHY

March 23:

Pateman, “The Sexual Contract” (Blackboard)

Group 1_____PB, MB, HB, TC, LR, NC_______

  • What is the function of the social contract?
  • Why is the social contract actually a fraternal contract?

Group 2____SD, IE, BG, AG, RV________

  • What is the difference between patriarchy and patriarchalism?
  • How do contract theorists deal with the problem that women would not agree to subordinate themselves to a husband?

Group 3_____HH, CM, NN, MP, DA_____

  • Who are the parties to the social contract?
  • How can women become civil individuals?

Firestone, Dialectic of Sex, chs. 1, 2, 4, 6, 7, Conclusion (pp. 232-7, 250-74)

Ch 1______PB, TC, BG, IE, DA_____

  • What is sex class? Why is it invisible?
  • Why is revolution the only solution?
  • What does Firestone want to borrow from Karl Marx?
  • What are the fundamental elements of the biological family?
  • What does it mean to say that human society is against nature?
  • What is the end or goal of the feminist revolution?
Ch 2______SD, HH, MP, HB, LR, NC___
  • What is the difference between a reformer and a feminist?
  • Why was the extension of suffrage a mixed bag for the W.R.M.?
  • What were the instruments of ridicule in the backlash that Firestone calls the “50-Year Ridicule.”
  • How were women convinced to return to the home after they had been drafted into the workforce during World War II?
  • Why are science and technology so essential to feminism? pp. 16-36
Ch  4______AG, CM, NN, MB, RV___
  • What is the relationship between patriarchy and matriarchy? p. 83
  • What is the purpose of childhood? How were children seen before childhood?
  • How was childhood different for girls and boys?
  • How did the privatization of family life bring more and more oppression?
  • What is the purpose of school?
Ch 6______IE, MP, CM, PB, RV, NC____
  • Do women want to get rid of love?
  • Is it a truism that women live for love and men for work?
  • What defines a successful love experience? What defines a destructive one?
  • Why, according to Firestone, can’t men love?
  • Why do women engage in “clinging” behavior?
  • How has women’s emancipation served men?
Ch 7______SD, HB, NN, TC, LR____
  • How is romance a tool for keeping women mystified?
  • What’s wrong with eroticism as currently enacted?
  • What does Firestone mean by the rediffusion of eroticism?
Conclusion, pp. 232-7, 250-74_____HH, AG, MB, BG, DA__
  • What are the components of the sexual revolution?
  • What is keeping marriage alive?
  • How are women worse off than they were when marriage was an economic arrangement?
  • What are single professions?
  • What is Firestone’s proposal for parenthood?
  • What are the most significant changes that have occurred since the publication of The Dialectic of Sex?

March 30:

hooks, Ain’t I a Woman? (Blackboard)

Group 1_____SD, TC, MB, MP, RV______

  • How has black women’s experience with patriarchy differed from white women’s? How has it been similar?
  • Why did 19th-century black women support patriarchy?
  • Why have black men been less likely to romanticize labor?
  • How has birth control changed men’s view of women?

Group 2____HB, HH, BG, CM, DA______

  • Why has the figure of the pimp been glorified?
  • Why were black women attracted to the Nation of Islam?
  • Why do black men prize white women?
  • How do white women think of racism? What do they miss?

Group 3____NN, AG, IE, PB, LR, NC_________

  • What is hooks’ critique of the feminist movement?
  • How have white women stigmatized black women?
  • What motive did white feminists have for excluding black women?
  • Is joining the workforce a sign of feminist progress?
  • How did slavery create a new status for white women?

Butler, Gender Trouble, pp. 1-25 (Blackboard)

Group 1_____SD, TC, MB, MP, LR_________

  • What is a woman?
  • Why is the question of the subject so important?
  • What’s wrong with the masculine/feminine binary?

Group 2____HB, HH, BG, CM, DA, NC________

  • Can we escape representational politics?
  • What is the difference between sex and gender?
  • How is the body itself a construction?

Group 3____NN, AG, IE, PB, RV_______

  • Why is the feminine defined by absence?
  • When are gendered identities disallowed?
  • What does it mean to think of gender as performative?

RACISM

April 6:

Mills, The Racial Contract, Introduction, chs. 1-3, MIDTERM

Intro_____MP, CM, PB, DA, NC________

  • Why isn’t white supremacy taught in political theory classes?
  • What is the racial contract?
  • What is the appeal of contract theory? What is the difference between ideal contract theory and a naturalized account? p. 5
  • What are the moral, political, and epistemological contracts?
  • In what way do all white people benefit from the racial contract?

Ch. 1___MB, BG, IE, LR_____________

  • To whom does the racial contract apply?
  • What does Mills make of colonial edicts to respect the rights of native peoples?
  • What is the relationship between humanism and racism?
  • What is the role of economics in the racial contract?
  • Why is European economic development depicted as autochthonous? What is the actual explanation for European economic dominance?
  • What role does Japan play in Mills’ argument?
  • What are Mills’ criticisms of social contract theory?
Ch 2___TC, HH, NN, RV____________
  • What is spacing? What are its epistemological and moral dimensions?
  • What role does terra nullius play in the racial contract?
  • What role does white fear play in the racial contract?
  • What is the origin of racism?
  • Who, according to Mills, lives in the state of nature?
  • How does racism persist even after it is written out of “formal existence?”
  • How is it possible that a claim of racelessness can itself be a racial act?
  • How does Mills address the fact that the West has also targeted whites for discrimination and persecution? pp. 79-81
Ch 3_____SD, HB, AG, NC___________
  • How does Mills’ argument change the way we view the Holocaust? How does it explain the supposed exceptional nature of the Holocaust?
  • How do whites choose to reject the racial contract? Give some examples. pp. 108-9
  • Why is the racial contract superior to the raceless social contract in an explanatory sense?
  • Why is the racial contract excluded from mainstream political theory?
  • If race is not biological, if it is “sociopolitical,” why can’t it simply be eliminated as a category of analysis?
  • At the end of the book, Mills raises the problem of how to integrate black critique into political theory more generally. How might we do this?

April 13:

Ta-Nehisi Coates, “Case for Reparations,” (Blackboard) and Between the World and Me; Johnson, “An Open Letter to Ta-Nehisi Coates and the Liberals Who Love Him” (Blackboard)

Group 1___HH, HB, CM, PB, DA_______

  • What lies between the world and Coates?
  • What role does atheism play in Coates’ worldview?
  • Why does Coates emphasize the black body?
  • What does it mean to say that “race is the child of racism?”

Group 2____NN, AG, MB, IE, RV___

  • How do people become black and white?
  • How are white people held accountable for brutalizing black people?
  • What is the significance of Howard University for Coates?
  • What is the Dream? Why is Coates wary of it?

Group 3____SD, MP, BG, TC, LR, NC_____

  • What are the unique burdens borne by young black men?
  • How does Coates connect the Dream to the murder of Prince Jones? To the urban violence in Chicago?
  • What makes someone black, according to Coates?
  • What did Coates learn from Paris?
  • White people made black people into a race. Black people mads themselves into a people. (P.149) what is the meaning of this claim?

Coates, “Case for Reparations”

Group 1__SD, MP, BG, TC, LR____

  • Why did Clyde Ross move to Chicago?
  • How were black people cut out of the home mortgage market from the 1930s-60s?
  • What are the arguments against reparations?
  • What are Coates’ criticisms of Bernie Sanders?
  • What was the wealth accorded to America by slavery?

Group 2___NN, AG, MB, IE, RV, NC____

  • How did the government preserve racial segregation in housing?
  • Who were the “contract sellers”?
  • Why hasn’t “adhering to middle-class norms” worked for African Americans?
  • What would reparations look like?

Johnson, “A Response to Coates”

Group 3___HH, HB, CM, PB, DA_____

 

  • What are Johnson’s criticisms of reparations?
  • What is Johnson’s critique of the Democratic Party?
  • Why did the reparations demand emerge after Jim Crow collapsed?
  • What does Johnson like about Coates’ essay on reparations?
  • What policies does Johnson favor to improve the lives of black people?

POPULISM

April 20:

Kazin, Populist Persuasion, pp. 1-133

Group 1___MP, TC, AG, LR_____

  • Kazin begins by quoting Carl Sandburg, “Who shall speak for the people?”  Why can’t the people speak for themselves? p. 1
  • What is so compelling about the distinction between the powerful and the powerless? p. 1
  • What is the “language of populism?” p. 1
  • Who do populists celebrate? pp. 1-2
  • Why is American populism unique? pp. 1-2
  • “Populism” is “more an impulse than an ideology.”  What does Kazin mean by this? p. 3
  • Why did populism move from the left to the right in the late 1940s? p. 4
  • What were George Wallace’s primary arguments? p. 5
  • How did the “New Left” respond to Wallace’s success? p. 5
  • How did the New Left’s response to Wallace’s success ultimately benefit the right? p. 5
  • What is the primary question Kazin’s text is intended to answer? p. 6
  • What does Kazin admire about populism? What does he fear about it? pp. 6-7

Group 2___CM, IE, HH, RV_______

  • Describe the populist themes in the cartoon on p. 8.
  • What were Thomas Jefferson’s and Publius’ arguments in favor of the “middling sort?” p. 9
  • What were the two strains of the “embryonic populist rhetoric” in antebellum American? p. 10
  • What was the relationship between the two strains in the 19th century? p. 11
  • What are the four clusters of populist belief? p. 11
  • “Speakers and writers transformed the country from a mere place on the map to an ideology.”  What is the meaning of this claim? p. 12
  • What was producerism? p. 13
  • What made one a producer? p. 14
  • Why weren’t women factory workers considered producers?   Who else was excluded from the class of producers? p. 14
  • Why did black activists resist joining the populist movement? p. 15
  • What were the characteristics of the “elite?” p. 15
  • What was the role of movements in populism? p. 16

Group 3___BP, NN, HB, DA, NC______

  • For Jefferson, what did it mean to be a republican? An anti-republican? p. 18
  • What were the goals of Jacksonian populism? p. 19
  • How does the Bank of the U.S. illustrate the dangers of populism? pp. 20-21
  • Where did populism come down on the question of slavery? p. 21
  • How did Jackson’s biography fuel his populist credentials? p. 22
  • How did Lincoln’s biography fuel his populist credentials? p.23
  • What are the populist themes in the political cartoon on p. 26?
  • What was the motive for forming the People’s Party (1892)? pp. 27-8
  • Who were the constituents of the People’s Party? How do they compare to the Tea Party? p. 28
  • What was the platform of the People’s Party? p. 29
  • Why did populist activists decide that a Jackson or Lincoln could not no longer be elected? p. 30

Group 4___MB, SD, BG, NC_______

  • Why did populist reformers break with the Republicans? p. 31
  • Why and how did populists invoke Christianity? p. 33
  • Why were populists often opposed to immigration? p. 36
  • What were the conditions for black inclusion into the populist movement? p. 36
  • What did the Populist Party propose? p. 38
  • Why did the Populist Party choose not to address race? p. 40
  • How did the Populist Party propose to increase the power of the state? p. 42
  • What arguments did William Jennings Bryan make? p. 44
  • Why was the 1896 election so pivotal? p. 45

Group 5__CM, TC, SD, RV______

  • What is included and excluded in the cartoon printed on p. 48?
  • “…if the great industrial combinations do not deal with us they will have somebody to deal with who will ont have the American idea.” (p. 49)  What is Gompers threatening?
  • What contribution did the muckrakers make to populist discourse? p. 51
  • How did the Progressives change populist discourse?  How did their view of “the people” change p. 51
  • Why was an alliance between labor and progressives “never fully consummated?” p. 54
  • How did Samuel Gompers define “John Public?” p. 57
  • What was the AFL’s response to immigrants? pp. 59-60
  • How did the unions pick their enemies? p. 62
  • Why did the unions refrain from vilifying capitalists? p. 63
  • How did the unions feel about government power? p. 63
  • Why did unions fear the government? p. 64
  • How did unions criticize the judiciary? p. 64
  • “The average citizen cannot understand how this judicial shell game is worked.  When he comes to thoroughly understand it there will be doings.” (p. 65)  Do Americans understand the judiciary?
  • What language did the unions speak?  p. 65
  • What was the radicals’ dilemma? p. 66

Group 6____BP, BG, HH, LR______

  • Why were workers suspicious of U.S. involvement in WWI? p. 69
  • Why did the AFL ultimately support WWI? pp. 69-70
  • What was the populist argument against the WWI? p. 71
  • What did Woodrow Wilson do to win over labor? p. 72
  • Did the left overplay its hand after WWI? p. 73
  • Compare the language of advertising to the language of populism? p. 76
  • “Why is it?” (p. 78)  What is the artist’s answer to this question?
  • Why was Prohibition appealing? p. 80
  • How was liquor cast as a tool of exploitation? p. 81
  • What was the WCTU?  Why were women attracted to Prohibition? p. 82
  • What precipitated the split in populism after 1896? p. 85
  • What did the Anti-Saloon League have in common with the abolitionists? the unionists? p. 87

Group 7_____MP, MB, AG, DA______

  • Why did prohibitionists target the saloon rather than individuals? p. 90
  • For prohibitionists, what did the liquor industry represent or stand-in for? p. 90
  • What motivated the prohibition movement, according to Kazin? p. 93
  • How was prohibition used for right-wing (anti-immigrant) populism? p. 99
  • “The reign of tears is over.” (Billy Sunday, p. 101) Why didn’t Prohibition produce the results Sunday predicted? p. 101
  • How was the KKK able to take on the energy of the prohibition movement? p. 103
  • What did the KKK stand for?  What did it stand against? p. 104
  • What was the anti-Prohibitionists’ populism? p. 105

Group 8_____IE, NN, TC______

  • In the cartoon on p. 108, who is being depicted as the people and who as the enemies of the people? p. 108
  • How can Charles Coughlin reconcile the “rottenness of modern capitalism” with his vow to “strike against Communism?” p. 109
  • What was the nature of FDR’s populism? p. 113
  • Why is the radio suited to populism? p. 115
  • What was the basis of Coughlin’s populism? p. 118
  • What was Coughlin’s proposed solution to the problem posed by the money changers? p. 120
  • How is it possible to mobilize class without a discourse of class? p. 123
  • What was the role of nostalgia in Coughlin’s populism? p. 128-9
  • Why did Coughlin support fascism, and how much did he support it? p. 130
  • Can Coughlin’s populism be separated from his fascism? p. 132

April 21: SECOND INSTALLMENT OF STATUS REPORT DUE (1500 WORDS)

April 27:

Michael Kazin, The Populist Persuasion, pp. 134-292;

Group 1___SD, TC, MB, MP, DA, NC_____

  • What is industrial democracy, as depicted in the cartoon on p. 134?
  • What is the relationship between unions and democracy according to John L. Lewis? p. 135
  • What distinguished the CIO from other populist movements? p. 130
  • What was the CIO’s political agenda? p. 138
  • What accounts for Lewis’ downfall? pp. 155-6
  • Why did the CIO form the nation’s first PAC? p. 159
  • What was Mills’ criticism of the CIO PAC? pp. 160-1

Group 2___HB, HH, BG, CM, RV______

  • Why did labor’s power decline in the 1950s? p. 161
  • How did the unionists political rhetoric change in the 1950s? pp. 161-2
  • “Labor’s success was also its failure.” (162) Explain.
  • What are the populist themes in the cartoon on p. 164?  How have they changed from the earlier cartoons?
  • How did the Cold War open up possibilities of new populist discourse? p. 166
  • What did postwar conservatives jettison in their political rhetoric and policy positions? p. 167
  • Who is the enemy of the people in conservative populism? p. 167

Group 3___NN, AG, IE, PB, LR_________

  • What role did masculinity play in conservative populism? p. 170
  • What was the goal of conservative intellectuals? p. 171
  • What role did conspiracy play in conservative populism? p. 173
  • Why were Catholics attracted to conservative populism? p. 173
  • What was conservative populism’s definition of “the people?” p. 176
  • Who were the “real Americans,” according to Joseph McCarthy? p. 184
  • Why had white ethnics voted Democrat in in the 1930s? p. 186
  • How did Republicans believe McCarthy could bring them back? p. 186

Group 4______PB, MB, HB, TC, RV______

  • Why was Joseph Welch’s attack on McCarthy so effective? p. 189
  • How did intellectuals’ conception of themselves change in the 1950s? p. 191
  • What did Populist campaigners share with conservative anti-communists? p. 192
  • What are the populist themes in the cartoon on p. 194?
  • How was the New Left more radical than previous populist movements? p. 197
  • What is radical in Tom Hayden’s Port Huron Statement? p. 198
  • What was the agenda of the participatory democracy movement? p. 198

Group 5______HH, CM, NN, MP, DA______

  • What were the political costs of jettisoning the implicit exclusion of blacks? pp. 200-1
  • What did Saul Alinsky hope to achieve? pp. 202-3
  • Why did so many Americans turn aginst 60s radicalism on college campuses? p. 206-7
  • What success, if any, did the New Left have in recruiting working class support? p. 213
  • How did feminism undermine the left’s “traditional agenda?” p. 217
  • Who was the “enemy of the people” for Wallace? p. 221
  • Who are “the people” in the New Right’s populism? p. 223
  • Who are the enemies of the people in the New Right’s populism? p. 224

Group 6_____HH, CM, NN, MP, LR, NC_____

  • How did the right adopt MLK’s and LBJ’s language of rights? p. 227
  • What was Wallace’s “populist formula?” p. 231
  • How were states rights arguments deployed toward populist ends? p. 233
  • How did country music serve Wallace’s populism? p. 235
  • How did left intellectuals play into Wallace’s hands? p. 236
  • For Wallace, who were not “the people?” p. 240
  • “Women simply did not like George Wallace.” (p. 241) Why?

Group 7_____CM, BG, MB, HB, LR_

  • What are the populist themes in the cartoon on p. 244?  How have they changed from previous cartoons?
  • How did the new conservatives define “the people?” p. 246
  • “The labor-liberal alliance forged in the 1930s was the victim of its own success.” (p. 246) Explain.
  • What allowed conservatives to dominate national politics in the 1970s? p. 248
  • How did Nixon adapt Wallace’s populism? p. 250
  • What was the Nixon-Agnew message in 1972? p. 255
  • How did conservatives incorporate women? p. 258

Group 8__HH, NN, IE, TC, DA___

  • What comprised the “New Right,” as Kevin Phillips called it? p. 260
  • For Reagan, who was the enemy of the people? p. 262
  • How can presidents counter populist opposition? p. 265
  • What is wrong with our rhetoric, according the Robert Bellah? p. 269
  • How did the left try to revive a populist movement in the ’70s and ’80s? p. 276
  • What language did this revived left select?  What language did it avoid? p. 276
  • Who supported Jesse Jackson’s 1988 campaign?  Why didn’t this coalition prove successful? p. 280

Group 9___PB, MP, SD, AG, RV__

  • What was the New World Order? p. 281
  • Why did globalism fail to generate a mass populist movement? p. 285
  • According to Kazin, is populism good, bad, or neither? p. 287
  • Why is populism still heard mainly on the right? p. 288
  • Why, according to Kazin, is the desire to transcend populism shortsighted? p. 289
  • What is “connected criticism?” p. 289

May 4:

Thomas Frank, What’s the Matter with Kansas?, Introduction, pp. 1-35, 67-9, 75-7, 85-8, 89-96, 113-137, 157-9, 174-182, 191-95, 228-31, 237-51

Group 1___CM, HB, BG, HH, LR_____

  • Why does the poorest county in America vote Republican (in overwhelming numbers)? p. 1
  • What explanations does Frank offer? pp. 2-3
  • “Cultural anger is marshaled to achieve economic ends.” (p. 5) Explain.
  • What is the “Great Backlash?” p. 5
  • “Abortion is never halted.  Affirmative action is never abolished.  The culture industry is never forced to clean up its act.” (p. 6) Why?
  • How do liberals misunderstand the “Great Backlash?” p. 8

Group 2___CM, NN, MB, DA, NC____

  • What are the sides in the “quasi-civil war” of the “backlash imagination?” p. 13
  • Why is it a mistake to assume that the heartland is inherently conservative? p. 15
  • What is the “latte libel?” p. 16
  • What are David Brooks’ generalizations about “Blue America?”  What’s wrong with them? pp. 18-20
  • What are Brooks’ generalizations about “Red America?” What’s wrong with them? pp. 20-24
  • What’s wrong with Brooks’ model of society? p. 26

Group 3____HB, HH, TC, RV_______

  • What leads Frank to call early Kansas a “freak state?” p. 31
  • What were the Populists fighting for? pp. 32-34
  • How is it possible that Kansas is both average and freaky? p. 34
  • How have Kansans responded to their economic suffering? p. 68
  • What are the primary tenets of the Kansas Republican Party platform? p. 75
  • What does the story of Ulysses and Boeing illustrate? pp. 85-88

Group 4___MB, NN, IE, SD, NC_________

  • How does Frank use 1991 and Operation Rescue to describe the change in conservatism in Kansas? p. 91
  • How did Operation Rescue make use of disgust with “politics as usual?” p. 95
  • What made Kansas conservatives successful? p. 95
  • What separates the Mods from the Cons? p. 103
  • “In Kansas the political geography of social class has been turned upside down.” (p. 104)  What does Frank mean by this claim?
  • How have the upper classes in Kansas contributed to their image among the Cons? p. 107
  • How do the Mods benefit from class antagonism? p. 109

Group 5__TC, AG, PB, MP, LR_________

  • What is the basis of the class distinction in Kansas?
  • If there is a class war, then why is there “no resentment or class consciousness?” p. 114
  • What is the “liberal elite?”  How has it altered the predominant conception of class in America? p. 114
  • How have conservatives depicted themselves as victims? p. 119-120
  • What do conservatives see themselves subverting? p. 120
  • In what sense has the backlash been a “bust?” p. 121
  • Why are the Cons right to be angry? p. 133-4

Group 6____BG, IE, AG, DA_____

  • How does the conservative movement provide “an attractive and even a seductive way of dealing with an unfair universe?” p. 157
  • What makes the backlash “holy?” p. 168
  • What was triangulation?  Why was it bad political strategy? p. 176
  • Why doesn’t racism explain the backlash in Kansas? p. 179
  • Who is in charge of the country, according to the backlash? p. 191
  • How does anti-intellectualism serve the free market argument? p. 193
  • How has the “political valence of Vietnam-related martyrdom” been switched? p. 229

Group 7_____SD, PB, MP, RV________

  • What is the Kansas stereotype of liberals?  Where does it come from? p. 240
  • Why hasn’t the culture industry changed? p. 241
  • What does the backlash have in common with the commercial culture it derides? p. 242
  • What part did liberals play in the backlash? p. 242
  • What is the lesson in the Kansas story for Democrats? p. 245

SOCIALISM

May 11:

Eagleton, Marx Was Right, chs. 1-2, ch. 3 (pp. 30-36), ch. 5, ch. 7, chs. 9-10

Chs. 1, 2 ____SD, AG, NN, IE, LR________

  • Why do so many people believe Marxism is outdated? Why, according to Eagleton, are they wrong?
  • What did the “Marxist” societies of the 20th C accomplish? What were their shortcomings? Same question for the capitalist societies.
  • To what extent were the “Marxist” countries of the 20th C actually Marxist?
  • What are the social and cultural prerequisites to a true socialist revolution?
  • What is the difference between socialism and Stalinism?
  • What is a market based economy? What is a planned economy? What is market socialism? What is Eagleton’s proposal for a negotiated middle ground between a planned economy and a market economy?

Ch. 3 (pp. 30-36), Ch. 4___PB, HB, MB, CM, RV, NC____

  • What is distinctive about Marx’s philosophy?
  • What is the meaning of Marx’s claim that the “history of all previously existing societies is the history of class struggle?”
  • How did Marx distinguish himself from utopian socialism?
  • Why didn’t Marx have much to say about how society would look after the revolution?
  • How does Eagleton respond to the charge that communism would require a transformation of human nature?
  • Why is capitalism more conformist than socialism?

Chs. 5 and 7_____MP, HH, BG, TC, LR____

  • What role does economics play in history?
  • How does Eagleton respond to the charge that Marx reduces all of history to economics?
  • How does Marxism define class? What makes one working class?
  • What makes one middle class? How is the middle class being proletarianized?

Ch. 9__NN, HB, MP, TC, DA________

  • What part of the state does Marxism seek to dismantle? Why?
  • How would the state change under socialism? Answer with respect to the Paris Commune.
  • What is the dictatorship of the proletariat?

Ch. 10___AG, PB, MB, BG, RV, NC_________

  • Does Marxism neglect race and gender as sites of oppression? Colonialism?
  • What is the relationship between nationalism and socialism? Between environmentalism and socialism?
  • What is Eagleton’s critique of postcolonialism?

Keema Yamghatta-Taylor, “ABC’s of socialism” (Blackboard)

Group 1__SD, IE, CM, HH, DA_________

  • What is the role of racism in capitalism? What is the role of capitalism in racism?
  • What role did slavery play in the development of capitalism?
  • Why do socialists tend to be anti-racists?
  • Why aren’t general policies favoirng econmic expansion sufficient to address racism?
  • Why have African Americans gravitated toward socialism?

ANARCHISM

May 18:

Scott, Two Cheers for Anarchism, chs. 1-3, 5

Ch. 1______MP, TC, SD, PB, LR, NC____

  • What attracts Scott to anarchism?
  • How does Scott define anarchism?
  • What is an anarchist squint? What does it enable us to see?
  • Why only two cheers for anarchism?
  • What is the paradox of organization?
  • What are anarchist calisthenics?
  • Why is disordered resistance usually more effective?
  • How is charisma anarchic?
Ch. 2, 3_____HH, IE, AG, HB, RV_____
  • How can vernacular order be superior to official order? Give an example.
  • Where do large-scale modernist schemes come up short? Give an example.
  • What is Scott’s critique of visual order?
  • What do the Vietnam Memorial and Emdrup playground have in common?
  • Why does Scott favor thinking about the workplace in terms of capacities rather than efficiency?
  • Where does Scott see authoritarianism in American society? What are the consequences of these forms of authoritarianism?
  • How does removing all traffic signs signals and regulations make streets safer and people happier?
Ch. 5_____BG, CM, NN, MB, DA____
  • Why is Scott opposed to standardized tests?
  • What’s wrong with quantitative measurements of merit?
  • What happens when a measure becomes a target?
  • What is the appeal, and what are the disadvantages of quantitative measures of merit?
  • What is cost benefit analysis? What are its shortcomings?

May 19: FINAL INSTALLMENT OF STATUS REPORT DUE

Final Exam: May 25, 3:30 pm

STYLE GUIDE:

The Department of History and Political Science mandates that all submitted work adhere to the Turabian/Chicago style delineated in Kate Turabian, et. al., A Manual for Writers of Term Papers, Theses, and Dissertations, University of Chicago Press (available at the Wilson Library Reference Desk).

EXAM PROCTORING GUIDELINES:

  1. One seat space between students when possible.
  2. No bathroom breaks except in the case of illness or emergency.  Student should discuss this circumstance with the proctor prior to the start of the exam.
  3. No materials on the desk except for pens/pencils, bluebook or writing paper and exam.
  4. Under no circumstances can students access electronic devices during the exam.
  5. Exam proctors will note any violation of these rules and those will be considered in the final grade.

GRADING:

Your work will be evaluated according to the following criteria:

A—designates work of extraordinarily high quality; reflects unusually thorough and comprehensive understanding of issues at hand; presents a clearly identifiable thesis and argument that demonstrates cogent and creative development and support of ideas.

B—designates work of high quality; reflects clearly organized and comprehensive understanding of issues and hand; presents substantive thesis and argument with evident development and support of ideas.

C—designates work which minimally meets requirements set forward in assignment; reflects some organization and development of ideas, but develops argument in superficial or simplistic manner; may only address part of the assignment or be otherwise incomplete.

D—designates work of poor quality which does not meet minimum requirements set forward in assignment; demonstrates poor organization of ideas and/or inattention to development of ideas, grammar, and spelling; treatment of material is superficial and/or simplistic; may indicate that student has not done reading assignments thoroughly.

F—designates work that does not meet ANY of the standards set above or which is not handed in.

PLAGIARISM:

Plagiarism is a prevalent but highly unethical practice. Plagiarism will result in the immediate failure of this course and disciplinary action which could lead to expulsion from the University. If you are having problems in the course, please come and talk to me about it rather than doing something that could put your entire college career in jeopardy. Plagiarism includes, but is not limited to the following:

  • The direct copying of any source, such as written and verbal material, computer files, audio disks, video programs or musical scores, whether published or unpublished, in whole or part, without proper acknowledgment that it is someone else’s.
  • Copying of any source in whole or part with only minor changes in wording or syntax, even with acknowledgment.
  • Submitting as one’s own work a report, examination paper, computer file, lab report or other assignment that has been prepared by someone else. This includes research papers purchased from any other person or agency.
  • The paraphrasing of another’s work or ideas without proper acknowledgment.

Anarchism

Scott, Two Cheers for Anarchism

Rationalism and Religion

Marilynne Robinson, harper’s essay and death of adam

Letter on humanism & question concerning technology, heidegger

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s